Neulander actually starts to carry Leslie’s system on the horizon, from the shower and on Jenna’s glance at

Neulander actually starts to carry Leslie’s system on the horizon, from the shower and on Jenna’s glance at

They hold the woman mommy to an area correct outside the toilet and you can Jenna claims it’s when this occurs, she requires a cordless phone from this lady mother’s dressing space, and reconnects into 911 operator

Fitzpatrick believes Jenna drops the phone plus the name catches, mere seconds later, the specific second when she first notices her mommy: while the Dr. It’s after that she allows loose a-cry regarding pure anguish:

“Once the mundane as it is to know, it’s inconceivable one to you to definitely telephone call was one thing besides an excellent statement out-of shame facing the girl father,” said Fitzpatrick.

Nevertheless the defense says a comparable call shows Dr. Neulander’s innocence –when Jenna incurs the restroom, there’s no blood toward walls but really. Jenna testifies she accumulates the phone by toilet, falls they because it isn’t really doing work while you are race to aid their dad. From the shelter evaluate, this is how Jenna observes bloodstream toward, and as much as, her mother. This is when she yells, “There is certainly bloodstream everywhere. “

“The fresh new defense’s undertake that is you to definitely the lady mother can be obtained, facing the lady, and she actually is responding so you’re able to the lady mother, the newest blood that’s on her behalf mother and perhaps bloodstream into wall structure and on the ground also,” said Stevens.

“One aids the idea that very first time she noticed bloodstream, she was thinking about their mom,” Axelrod indexed so you’re able to Stevens.

The latest D.A beneficial, though, will not faith Jenna could try everything she states do inside the 13 moments the newest 911 name was toward hold. Fitzpatrick tried it themselves and you can states it took him about 50 moments.

There is one other section of Jenna’s testimony which are essential. She tells the fresh new jury you to due to the fact her father is maintaining the woman mommy on bed room, she noticed him stop a blood-over loaded shirt and you will put they aside. Now think of, brand new defense ideal that tossing which bloody shirt may have caused a few of the bloodstream splatter from the rooms. But the top is never discover.

“She’d say no,” Fitzpatrick said. “Really don’t believe in her own mind Jenna believes one to the lady dad performed that it. I do believe this woman is composed a protective globe in her attention in which mother tucked and you will fell on bath.”

“I am concerned that they are which have a difficult response to the agony associated with lady. . They already know that this lady wishes these to choose simple. Plus they know that so it sixty-plus-year-old defendant is actually unlikely in order to reoffend,” Fitzpatrick informed me. “And all sorts of men and women attitude could play with the hindrance of situation one to becoming confirmed beyond a good doubt.”

The fresh Decision

Immediately after eight arduous times of testimony, District Attorney Statement Fitzpatrick treated the newest jury one last time having closing objections, asking them to pay close attention to new actual research — especially the brand new bloodstream splatter on the walls as well as the wounds to help you Leslie Neulander’s system.

“Whenever i told you a couple of times from the demo, Leslie usually speak with your, women and you may gentlemen. You have got to hear the woman,” he advised Axelrod. “Also to including pay attention very carefully towards the terminology out of Jenna Neulander in this vital 911 name.”

But there’s things the new D.A. cannot share with the fresh jury: just what the guy suspects are this new purpose one delivered Robert Neulander toward good murderous outrage one to day. Investigators read regarding a friend of the Neulander friends one Leslie is actually thinking about signing a lease for yet another flat toward your day she passed away.

“Leslie try on her behalf way out. And this refers to maybe not a man that can handle that,” Fitzpatrick advised Axelrod.